Friday, 20 November 2026

Bury St Edmunds Cathedral I Context and exterior


     Today is the feast day of St Edmund, the King of East Anglia who was martyred c869.  The popularity of his cult was such that in the Middle Ages he was thought of as one of England's patron saints.  What better day then to publish my post about Bury St Edmunds cathedral.

     In the midst of the twentieth century the Church of England was still in an expansive mood.  Historic dioceses were being subdivided and new dioceses created.  The foundation of the see of St Edmundsbury is a case in point; in 1914 the old diocese of Norwich, which was essentially the former Kingdom of the East Angles, and consisted of the counties of Norfolk and Suffolk, was cleaved in twain - the dioceses of Norwich, and St Edmundsbury and Ipswich.  It was said that Ipswich got the bishop and Bury St Edmunds the cathedral, but perhaps there were no other option. Bury, in the Middle Ages, had been the most important religious foundation in the county.  A place of pilgrimage, the resting place of the Royal martyr, Edmund, King of the East Angles.  A shrine of national importance, the place where in 1214 the Barons swore an oath to resist King John's misgovernance. The medieval abbey church had been enormous, some 500ft long and 246 ft across the western transepts.  It was surrounded in turn by a vast precinct, and immediately to the west a planned town laid out on a grid c.1080.  Amongst a plethora of other buildings, including Royal lodgings, and two magnificent gate towers, the precinct contained two huge 'wool churches' built to serve the towns folk: St James and St Mary.
     The abbey was dissolved in 1539; the abbey church was demolished, the land sold off, the Abbot's Palace became a secular dwelling and rest the abbey buildings became a quarry.

     As to the early history of the abbey, things, as such things are often wont, get a little complicated.  There is still a lot of academic debate on the actual events.  The foundation of the abbey is traditionally credited to an earlier martyred King, Sigebert of East Anglia, in 633.  There is no hard evidence for this story.  The first reference to it is from the 12th century Liber Eliensis, written in the monastery of Ely. Such a claim could simply be a monastic fabrication in connection to claims of land ownership. Either way, sometime after the martyrdom of King Edmund in 869 his body was translated to Bury (then called Beodricsworth).  Wiki assigns this to the reign of King Athelstan.  It seems that a college of secular priest was established c.945 to run the shrine and that eighty years later, or so, the priests were expelled for the establishment of the Benedictine monastery.
 
     Like the new cathedrals at Bradford, Blackburn, Sheffield and Portsmouth Suffolk's cathedral was to be formed from an existing parish church.  (The confidence of the CofE only stretching so far.)  In preference to the church of St Mary to the south, it was decided that the church of St James, standing hard in front of the remains of the once mighty west front, was to be the core of the new cathedral.  An understandable choice, not only intimately bound in a dense urban and historical context, it possesses a vast nave by one of the most important English mason/architects of the late Middle Ages, John Wastell.**  St James's also had the advantage of a having a 'small' Victorian chancel, by Sir George Gilbert Scott, that could be easily demolished for any extension scheme.  (At a time when Victorian architecture was suffering from a prolonged critical reaction.)
     However, such a scheme had to wait another fifty years before any ground was broken, but then that half century was hardly auspicious.  Two World Wars, a massive economic slump, a relatively sluggish Post-war economy.  Two schemes were proposed by the very able Sir Walter Tapper, and I believe, most likely erroneously, one scheme, by the estimable Charles Nicholson, who worked at Chelmsford, Sheffield, and Portsmouth.

     In 1945 the church architect Stephen Dykes Bower (1903-1994) was appointed to the cathedral.  The  choice was a deliberate rejection of Modernism, for Dykes Bower was a traditionalist architect, working mainly in the Gothic style.  The post war years, you have to remember, were the hightide of British Modernism, and its doctrinaire, if not authoritarian, control of British architecture.  The third of British architecture's spasmodic dogma driven pursuits of purity, both stylistic and moral.  Modernism, it was argued, would lead to a moral and spiritual cleansing.  Architecture as 'spilt religion'.  It is interesting, to me at least however, how both the marriage of Modernism & the Post War Settlement and the physical structure of the cathedral itself offer, perhaps competing, visions of the 'New Jerusalem'.  One has certainly outlived the other.
     Dykes Bower retained the Late Medieval nave cathedral, extending the building eastwards with short n & s transepts, and an aisled chancel.  In a move that perhaps would not be acceptable today the chancel extends dramatically to within a mere few feet of the west front of the abbey.  On the n side of the nave, a new porch, and cloister were constructed, linking the porch to a long service wing stretching north from the chancel.  To celebrate the Millennium the construction of the cathedral was bought to a triumphant conclusion a soaring central tower based on a design by Dykes Bower.  It was the work of The Gothic Design Practice under Warwick Pethers.
       The result of this decades long process is actually something quite extraordinary.  The best of all the parish church cathedrals of the 20th century, undertaken with sensitivity, confidence and thoroughness, Dykes Bower designing everything from screens, monuments, and furniture down to door handles.  Except that in the local context it was, for a moment in time, not that exceptional or extraordinary.  For while the the cathedral was under construction, across town three classical public buildings were being built by traditionalist architectural practice of McMoran & Whitby.  The New Shire Hall (1965), the Police Station, and the best of the three the Public Library of 1963-65.  I can't think of another community who consistently opted for a Traditionalist approach to its public buildings.  Good for them.

     The w front of Wastell's nave could hardly be more unprepossessing - a flat façade, hard by the pavement on a busy street, the gable is by Gilbert Scott.  No tower.  The street, Angel Hill, is connects the great place of Angel Hill and the more intimate Chequer Square to the south.  The n and s side of the nave received a different treatment: rubble on the n (including spolia), and smooth ashlar on the s, the show side.  Such an economy is understandable as the stone (greyish Ooltic Limestone) had to be brought all the way by boat across the Fens to Bury from the Limestone Belt.  It may also explain the reticence of the west front.
     On the north side of the w front is the porch, the first part of the extension completed (1960).  The stone here appears warmer in tone than that of the nave, and the architecture that bit more elaborate.  It was planned at one point to demolish the Georgian buildings along Angel Hill, and I am very pleased that didn't happen. Nothing would have been gained in the exposure of the ruinous precinct wall and too much history lost.  
    Just to the south of the cathedral stands the Norman Gate of the abbey, an extraordinary, spectacular piece of Romanesque architecture, constructed of limestone from the quarries at Barnack, in the Soke of Peterborough. There's really nothing else surviving like it in the country.  Particularly impressive is the consistency of the decoration on all four elevations.  It serves as the cathedral bell tower.  It is aligned to Churchgate St.
     Like the n porch the eastward extension is designed in an early form of Perp, even heading off in the direction of the Decorated style in the tall clearstory of the chancel.  Flushwork is used extensively.  Work began on the east end in 1967 and worked its way west to meet the Late Medieval nave in 1970; the eagle eyed will notice a change in detail between the chancel and the transept.  Dykes Bower's being more Picturesque, perhaps restless and certainly eclectic in comparison to Wastell's lucid, rather rational architecture. As will be seen inside, the chancel has a rather brittle, metallic quality that is associated with the French Rayonant Style.
   On the north side of the cathedral things are a shade more utilitarian, and more complex.












** We have encountered his work before at Peterborough, at St Mary's in Cambridge.  It was he who completed King's College Chapel, and built the Bell Harry tower at Canterbury. 




Further reading:

The Cathedrals of England, Scotland and Wales, Anthony New, Constable London, 1981

Stephen Dykes Bower, Fr Anthony Symondson SJ, RIBA Publishing, 2011


Tuesday, 10 November 2026

St Bartholomew-the-Less


     Hidden away from Smithfield, in the grounds of St Bart's, is a small parish church, St Bartholomew-the-less. Very unprepossessing, simple Late Medieval tower of rubble masonry, plastered aisles.  An almost village feeling.  It could be almost anywhere in south-east England.

     Inside, a centrally planned Gothick church of about 1793 by that very interesting architect George Dance the Younger.  A paraphrase of Late Antiquity, fitting very well with 18th century, pre-Tractarian Anglicanism, with its emphasis on 'primitive' Christianity, what today is called the Patristic Period/Era.  Rather like another church by Dance, St Mary, Micheldever, Hampshire.* Not what one would expect at all. It's rather like entering an enormous chapter house.  A bit too cool for my tastes, but verging upon the sublime.  Subjected to a thorough-going nineteenth century restoration by P C Hardwick in 1862-3, incl tracery in the clearstory windows where none existed before, and rebuilding the apse in French Gothic style.  Compare and contrast below.  Numerous monuments.








St Bartholomew the Less, Smithfield, London, the interior with a churchwarden standing in the aisle. Zincograph by W. A. Delamotte, 1844. Wellcome Collection. Public Domain Mark. Source: Wellcome Collection. https://wellcomecollection.org/works/pukzxred








*And there is also St Dunstan-in-the-West, on Fleet St, 1830-3 by John Shaw senior.



Monday, 9 November 2026

St Bartholomew's Hospital


     Back to my visit to 'The Smoke'.  After the Richard Dadd exhibition, I did some shopping on Jermyn St and Piccadilly before a hurried Pret lunch and the Metropolitan train into the City.  My goal was Smithfield and St Bart's Hospital and the recently restored Great Hall & Hogarth Stair.  As you can see from the photographs it was a wet and miserable afternoon.  We remain, however, in the same cultural world as Burlington House, and the early 18th century 'battle of the styles'.
 
     So, as usual, a little history.  St Bartholomew's Hospital was founded by Rahere in 1123.  He is a semi-mythical - real though many stories and legends have been spun around him.  I am sure, for instance, that as a child I was told (by the children's magazine programme 'Blue Peter', no less) that Rahere was  court jester to King Henry I.  In other accounts he was a minstrel.  Either way, after a misspent life, he went on pilgrimage to Rome and there suffered a 'life changing illness', repented, and entered into the priesthood.  Or something like that.  Rahere's initial foundation also included the Augustinian Priory of St Bartholomew.  The east end survived the Reformation and now forms the wonderfully atmospheric parish church of St Bartholomew-the-great, where you will also find a fine Late Gothic tomb on the north side of the chancel purportedly Rahere's burial place, see below.  A church where one can feel the old London, before the glossy towers took over. (In fact if you want to experience that old densely-packed London of alleyways and chop houses I highly recommend a walk around the area to the north of the church.*)
     The hospital survived the Reformation, and the other vagaries of history and remains - uniquely among such City instituions? - on the same site.  In 1723 the architect James Gibbs was appointed to the Trustees, and work began, in the early 1730s, on the replacement of  medieval and later buildings.  Gibbs conceiving the new hospital as four separate, rather palatial-looking buildings, grouped rather formally round a square.  The North Wing, containing stairs and hall, was the first part of the hospital to be replaced, and as you can see from the print below, the North Wing has a different plan from the other blocks, being  shaped a little like a dumbbell.  The style of all four is vaguely neo-Palladian - a design that doesn't quite obey the strict rules of Burlingtonian Palladianism.  Both the proportions and the details, from that perspective, aberant. 
     The Great Hall is a vast, monumental space - a triple cube approx. 90 x 30 x 30 ft., occupying the entire first and second floor between the two terminal wings.  It was, perhaps, one of the largest secular spaces in the City when built. The Baroque plasterwork is by J B Michele, who also did the staircase ceiling.  The Hogarth staircase is in the eastern wing.  It is a dark, rich space.  Hogarth painted two vast canvasses 'The Pool at Bethseda' & 'The Good Samaritan', and others in his circle supplied the decorative panels.  It was, as I've said, a dull old day, and the there were conservation blinds in the windows, so perhaps it isn't fair to pass critical judgement, but I have to confess to a little disappointment.  A nice try and all that but not quite as good as his father-in-law James Thornhill.  It does, however, remain one of the few painted staircases of the that period to survive in London.

     Gibbs was one of the very few British architects to have trained under a serious European architect - maestro Carlo Fontana in Rome.  He was therefore steeped in the Roman Baroque tradition.  We have encountered Gibbs's work before at Wimpole Hall, in Cambridgeshire, and Houghton Hall in Norfolk.  Even considering the problems he encountered from the Palladian faction under the Earl of Burlington, it was a remarkable life - from rural Aberdeenshire, via Rome, to London.









Credit: St Bartholomew's Hospital, London: Elevation and a Plan of the Courtyard, with armorial Emblems of the Hospital and the Dedicatee.  Engraving after B Cole. Welcome Trust.











* there are other areas of this type to explore in the City: between Ludgate Hill & Victoria St; s of St Mary Le Bow; and s of Cornhill.



Sunday, 1 November 2026

The Burning of the Leaves


The Burning of the Leaves by Laurence Binyon (1869-1943)


Now is the time for the burning of the leaves.
They go to the fire; the nostril pricks with smoke
Wandering slowly into a weeping mist.
Brittle and blotched, ragged and rotten sheaves!
A flame seizes the smouldering ruin and bites
On stubborn stalks that crackle as they resist.

The last hollyhock's fallen tower is dust;
All the spices of June are a bitter reek,
All the extravagant riches spent and mean.
All burns! The reddest rose is a ghost;
Sparks whirl up, to expire in the mist: the wild
Fingers of fire are making corruption clean.

Now is the time for stripping the spirit bare,
Time for the burning of days ended and done,
Idle solace of things that have gone before:
Rootless hope and fruitless desire are there;
Let them go to the fire, with never a look behind.
The world that was ours is a world that is ours no more.

They will come again, the leaf and the flower, to arise
From squalor of rottenness into the old splendour,
And magical scents to a wondering memory bring;
The same glory, to shine upon different eyes.
Earth cares for her own ruins, naught for ours.
Nothing is certain, only the certain spring.